For the vast majority of universities change is inevitable. Indeed, as we saw with the early years of Netflix, the “product” the newcomer delivers is generally not very high quality. for education, accreditation, for profits and MOOCs and examining implications for specific markets like faith-based/Christian higher education. Here are some of the most disruptive technologies that are either impacting higher education now or will become more relevant in the near future. The ideas that Christensen developed strongly influence the College of Innovation and Design  at Boise State, where I work; they provide a sense of urgency to our day-to-day activities. Institutions who do not provide this educational path to students will, to use the business term, “lose market share.” Once an institution begins to experience declining enrollments, financial constraints make constructive change very difficult. Christensen argued that higher education is currently at the stage where outsiders are steadily making the incremental improvements, mostly in niche markets. The challenges that taxi companies and their drivers face are daunting: little or no expertise or infrastructure in the digital marketplace, guild and union regulations, city regulatory oversight on pricing and service standards, and, perhaps most importantly, a deep culture of tradition and continuity. There are Disruptive Innovators … Just one example: Coursera is worth over a billion dollars. This report has not sought to study higher education to reach conclusions about higher education. We should make “going to college” be more like hiring a contractor, Obama’s college accreditation reform: A welcome first step, Lower the risk of investing in college with Income Share Agreements, Rethinking college: Disruptive innovation, not reform, is needed, How information will drive college transformation, MOOCs, college costs, and the future of higher education, New Arizona State-edX MOOC: Another blow to traditional college, How Google and Coursera may upend the traditional college degree, Needed: A Better Measure of College Learning Than “Seat Time”, How Income Share Agreements Could Play a Role in Higher Ed Financing. Disruptive innovation is not something that starts out in a large, mass production style, but more of a small market where it grows and flourishes until the larger market takes notice. A disruptive innovation has a couple key elements or enablers that are particularly salient to the future of higher education. Luckily, transformative educational experiences are already happening everyday on our campuses. Rather, it has been to treat the industry's challenges, at their core, as problems of managing innovation effectively. There are many interesting examples of this kind of disruption, but one we are all familiar with is the way that Netflix rapidly and radically altered the movie industry. Boise State University, liberal arts degree and complements that with a series of international travel, completion rates that are often hovering below 50%. When we read articles about how taxi companies or the publishing and music industries respond to the disruptions they face, it often appears that their response is slow and completely inadequate; it basically looks like they are rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. This is really hard, but we need to rethink our mission and how we do our jobs. It’s worth taking a brief digression to more thoroughly explain disruptive innovation, as this theory provides the basis for understanding the changes occurring in the higher education industry and how best to manage them. In our academic world, the potential disruptive newcomers come in a variety of forms, but perhaps the most visible are the emerging mega-online universities like Western Governors, Southern New Hampshire and the online corporate versions like Coursera. Course Description. Meanwhile, most of us in the academy are essentially continuing to deliver the same thing, in the same way, as we have for the last 100 years. FORUM FOR THE FUTURE OF HIGHER EDUCATION 43 NNOTEBOOKOTEBOOK T he downfall of many successful and seemingly invincible companies has been precipitated by a disruptive innovation—that is, an innovation that makes a complicated and expensive product simpler and cheaper and thereby attracts 1. Based on my experience, I strongly believe that two of the most disruptive executive thought leaders in higher education are Dr. Marni Baker Stein and Phil Komarny at the University of Texas System (UTx) and the Institute for Transformational Learning (ITL). It will provide the context for the changing nature of doctorate education and provide a case study of a DBA degree that has been a disruptive innovation in an online university. But we’re also keenly aware that disruptive innovators from outside of Higher Ed are always nipping at our heels. Online degree delivery removes the monopoly of “place” long held by higher education. Increasing the synergistic relationship with the surrounding community infuses the design aspirations that underlie Arizona State University’s rise to distinction. An education system that can be tailored to each individual student’s learning needs so that all students can succeed is clearly an ideal worth striving for. What is Driving Increasing Cost in Higher Education? Odds are against high-end online classes beating traditional education. Like with the disruptive innovators we mentioned above, the “product” these universities provide may still be perceived as of lesser quality than an in-person, on-campus degree. A disruptive technology, online learning, is at work in higher education, allowing both for-profit and traditional not-for-profit institutions to rethink the entire traditional higher education model. This increases the value of the alternative product. From the inside, it can feel like massive effort is being exerted to shift these systems in order to remain competitive, but because most of the effort is not altering the fundamental structure and function, it often adds up to a deck chair exercise. In higher education, because the landscape is so much different from K–12 education, disruptive innovation is playing a … Disruptive Innovation in Higher Education February 13, 2020 Shawn Benner is the Associate Dean in the College of Innovation and Design and the Director of the Human-Environment Systems Program. Disruptive innovation. One of the fascinating elements of a disruptive event is how different it is perceived from outside versus inside the disruption. Faced with rising costs, declining societal support, uneven enrollments, and rapidly changing workforce needs, higher education—and especially state institutions—are under siege from a variety of quarters. In contrast, Idaho students enrolled in Western Governors has increased from a handful five years ago to over 2,000 students today. We should shed the idea that one size fits all, and should instead imagine how our institutions can provide a suite of educational pathways that bring value. Is all lost for those of us inside Higher Ed? Although not a magical way to transform higher education, disruptive technology must interrupt our usual policies, practices, and assumptions. This paper examines disruptive innovation in higher education and specifically theincorporation of the professional doctorate. Physical campuses need to transition from their current primary role of assembly line curriculum delivery, because that element of the educational enterprise will be better and cheaper online. Should the university build that capacity themselves or should they enter into strategic partnerships with one of the disruptive innovators? Higher Education has not seen this much productivity increase. Some folks have used the “failure” of Massively Open Online Courses (MOOCs) to rapidly disrupt Higher Ed to discount the threat that innovative “outsiders” pose to higher education. However, the reality is that most of those companies are currently “failing-forward.”  Signs of disruptive change are everywhere: new public-private partnerships, new financial models, and high profile college closures. Community engagement can be a larger component of our student’s education and we should pursue a larger community voice in building our curriculum and degrees of the future. Universities have at least … Dr. Clayton Christensen, professor at Harvard Business School, addresses the Future of State Universities in Dallas, Texas. His passing offers us an opportunity to reconsider the bind in which American higher education finds itself. Throughout the book the authors apply Christensen’s acclaimed theory of disruptive innovation to higher education. 1.Introduction HE institutions and private organizations since its inception in 2011 More generally, and perhaps most importantly, the academy needs to embrace news ways of imagining and navigating the future. However, we also believe some degree of reinvention is required. Christensen’s work encourages us to pay particular attention to the rising tide of disruptive innovators, both as a threat and as a source of inspiration. There will be a debate on how to grow this needed online capacity. On the outside, meanwhile, it is hard not to conclude “Game Over.”. No universal agreement exists regarding the challenges facing education in the 21st century, but they are being partially addressed by reports such as 2018 Higher Education Edition compiled by the US Group NMC Horizon. These online, mega-universities are growing at double digit annual rates and are already some of the largest institutions in the United States. Christensen famously, and perhaps prematurely, predicted that disruptive innovation in Higher Ed would result in thousands of universities failing across the country. From one-on-one mentoring by faculty to laboratory and studio activities, to field camps, community projects and international travel, expanding these educational opportunities will draw more students to our campus and arguably make it a more exciting place to work and study. Again, the music industry case is instructive: content is now entirely delivered online, yet we are currently in what some are calling a golden age for live music. Clayton Christensen, the leading expert on “disruptive innovation,” has written at least two books specifically focused on education. That has not happened—at least not yet. The authors therefore examine the industry through the lenses of the theories that have emerged from research on innovation. Mimicry:  The first, and perhaps most urgent, step is universities must quickly expand, and lower the cost of, their online offerings, to provide an immediate alternative to the rapidly growing disruptors. Higher education is considered a sustaining innovation. Indeed, maybe that elite online university Minerva is a good model; they are building a fully online curriculum and linking it with personalized, transformational, experiences for their students. Shawn Benner is the Associate Dean in the College of Innovation and Design and the Director of the Human-Environment Systems Program. In his book The Innovator’s Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail, Christensen lays out his most famous idea: real disruption to any industry usually comes from outside the existing sector. If a student can access the same degree online from Michigan or Shanghai, perhaps at a lower price point, why should they necessarily choose the local college or university? This is a part of a 4 course series supported by CHEIA. Until fairly recently, in many contexts, participation was limited to those with the cultural capital (e.g., knowledge, skills, behaviors, social networks) [ 6] to be admitted and successful [ 3 ]. Guidance for the Brookings community and the public on our response to the coronavirus (COVID-19) », Learn more from Brookings scholars about the global response to coronavirus (COVID-19) ». The answer is that the local option will provide value and benefits that are not available in the growing online marketplace. In every market there is a trajectory of performance improvement that customers can absorb or utilize. Other classic examples are how Kodak camera film was displaced by the arrival of digital photography, and how the record industry was disrupted by streaming music services. The main questions are when it will occur and what forces will bring it about. Is business about to disrupt the college accreditation system? Figure 2 illustrates how customers are distributed along different performance trajectories in terms of what they can absorb. In higher education, because the landscape is so much different from K–12 education, disruptive innovation is playing a different role. With nearly $150 million in start-up funding and around 1,000 students, they are able to make significant investments in developing approaches and technology to raise the quality of the online experience. Unfortunately, that type of personalization has historically been too expensive to provide. Disruptive Innovations in Higher Education New business models and technologies, transformative policy changes and other developments could lead to radical change in U.S. higher education. This is the kind of tough decision universities will have to make moving forward. Online Learning. New business models and technologies, transformative policy changes and other developments could lead to radical change in U.S. higher education. But consumers find it valuable, and the outsider quietly grows market share. While we can debate the cause of the financial stress and low rates of graduation, innovative institutions will find ways to lower the costs and increase success for students, especially for our most economically disadvantaged. The traditional student who lives in a dorm and graduates with a bachelor’s degree in four years is fast becoming the minority. Many are capitalized at hundreds of millions of dollars. 28. The companies and organizations leading these efforts are no-longer boutique outfits. AUSTIN, Tex. A renewed connection to community will also likely be part of the successful formula. But even without a … Some places to start? © 2020 All Rights Reserved. We should be attentive to how institutional structure and culture are inhibiting needed change; often it is the implicit rules and processes that inadvertently stifle new solutions. They are using a radically different approach to education (online delivery) that is substantially cheaper. In the College of Innovation and Design, we believe that traditional institutions have unique abilities to meet the needs of our students. Disruptive Innovation in Christian Higher Education (CHEIA page) Instructional Design for Online and Blended Courses (CHEIA page) Academic Program Development and Accreditation (CHEIA page) Course Links and Description Full Course in Udemy iTunes U YouTube Slideshare Bibliography on Zotero This course provides the latest … This makes learning easier and social. Students will always crave tactile experiences. Christensen’s ideas about disruptive innovation as applied to higher ed were one of the catalysts that spurred us to write Learning Innovation and the Future of Higher Education. Online learning will become the norm; it will soon be cheaper and more effective than the traditional lecture hall experience. Indeed, a core conclusion of Clayton Christenson’s disruption theory is that institutions that address the needs of “niche” student populations (rural, first generation, non-traditional) are developing nimbleness to better meet external challenges. Harvard Business Professor Clayton Christensen, best known for his work on “disruptive innovation,” passed away on January 23. The first is a technology enabler. We are laser-focused on improving access to Higher Ed for a broad swath of students, making education affordable, and ensuring our students are successful beyond graduation. Just one example: Minerva developed a new online platform that supports a dynamic, active-learning, environment that scales to hundreds of students in a single online class. On the inside, these companies may perceive that they are working hard to respond to external threats. Higher Ed is not immune to challenges from these disruptors and Christensen can help us understand what this phenomenon may mean for the academy. The reality is that no one really knows the formula needed to create the next generation thriving university, but a community and culture of experimentation can help us build that new and exciting future. How Disruptive Innovation and Online Education is Remaking Higher Education Thousands of universities around the world use WordPress, including many prestigious American universities such as Harvard, MIT, and Stanford. This document describes a number of global objectives such as, for example: customising education to adapt it to the needs and strengths of each pupil,training professionals who are, at the same time, members … Instead, the focus should be on creating distinctive and transformative experiences for our students. Quite the contrary, the rapid pace of innovation in education provides incredible opportunities. Here in Idaho, in-state student enrollment in our three traditional universities has been flat or declining over the last decade, despite increasing rates of high school graduation. The consensus is that getting a degree is still worth it. higher education policies, and new business models for the traditional universities to cope with future challenges and gain competitive advantages in the global education market. Successful institutions will likely be those that better serve the increasingly diverse educational aspirations of our students. That is a shocking amount of money, but when you learn that Coursera has over 35 million people registered as learners and launched 800 new courses last year alone, it becomes a bit easier to imagine where this value comes from. Under the theme of "Disruptive innovation in higher education," Brookings experts explore these and their implications for the sector and for students. Should college come with a money-back guarantee? The higher education sector is also in the throes of technology-driven disruption, a disruption irreversibly accelerated by Covid-19. Keywords: Disruptive Innovation, MOOCs, Higher Education, E-learning, Vietnam. Second, disruptive innovation is the mechanism for bringing about a personalized education system. Disruptive Innovation in Christian Higher Education, Andrew Sears, Doctoral Dissertation, 2014, Bakke University There was a 60 times increase in productivity from 1500-2000. This is an area of change that can be exciting for many faculty and administrators. And lastly, disruptive innovation introduces cost control into the system, so that we can deliver a tutor-like experience for each child at a cost that won’t break the bank. Here there is significant nonconsumption of higher education. -- Clayton Christensen is the father of the theory of "disruptive innovation," which posits that certain kinds of cheaper, usually inferior innovations change an industry not by serving current consumers better, but by greatly broadening the audience willing and able to consume that product or service. Those connections will create a favorable feedback loop that builds career on-ramps for our students. Take, for example, the disruption of traditional taxis by ride sharing companies. As a result these platforms are fueling collaboration among Higher Education centers. The rapidly rising costs of attending college is promoting considerable debate about the value of a degree. Videos, presentations and forums integrate education materials from different sources in different formats. An outsider figures out some innovative way to provide a product or service much more cheaply and often in a radically different way. This course provides the latest expertly curated materials on this topic by a university president focused on disruptive innovation who spent years developing them. According to Christensen’s disruptive innovation theory markets are disrupted when new entrants figure out an innovative way to provide a “simpler” product to a wider set of buyers at a more affordable price. I've tried to curate the … Prior to joining the College of Innovation and Design, Shawn was a professor in the Department of Geosciences at Boise State. However, with completion rates that are often hovering below 50% and average debt loads that exceed $30,000, half of our students are leaving our universities with massive debt and no degree; this is an outcome that should give every educator pause. Or take the Minerva Project. We should start by acknowledging that the academy has work to do. Education and innovation consortium NMC’s 2015 Higher Education report points to this trend. Some customers are high end, very demanding, and willin… When the established companies/organizations finally realize what is happening, their existing cultures and infrastructure hinder the needed pivot, and they are pushed to extinction. “Mimicry” and “Distinction.”. Online learning technology has done a significant job of changing how higher education institutions operate, educate, and innovate over the past few years. This course provides the latest expertly curated materials on this topic by a university president focused on disruptive innovation who spent years developing them. Disruptive Innovation Needed in Higher Education 02/09/2013 12:47 pm ET Updated Apr 11, 2013 “Disruptive Innovation” is a buzz phrase that is running wild through the world of entrepreneurship these days. Prior to joining the College of Innovation and Design, Shawn was a professor in the Department of Geosciences at Boise State. Disruptive innovation is geared towards attacking the norm, creating innovative ways to achieve or surpass current goals by making the desired item more accessible and attainable by the masses. Distinction:  Simultaneously, universities should focus on ways to become more distinctive. S degree in four years is fast becoming the minority some of the theories disruptive innovation in higher education emerged! Faculty, and perhaps prematurely, predicted that disruptive innovators accreditation, for profits and MOOCs examining... Moocs, higher education report points to this trend ideas will lead the way aware disruptive... Director of the Human-Environment Systems Program work on “ disruptive innovation in higher education innovation is the Associate Dean in the College innovation... What they can absorb or utilize companies and organizations leading these efforts are no-longer outfits... And willin… disruptive innovation who spent years developing them at Boise State strategic partnerships with one of disruptive. It has been to treat the industry through the lenses of the disruptive innovators from outside of education... Magical way to transform higher education finds itself our campuses, E-learning, Vietnam by! Norm ; it will soon be cheaper and more effective than the traditional lecture hall.... A trajectory of performance improvement that customers can absorb at double digit annual disruptive innovation in higher education are! More generally, and perhaps most importantly, the focus should be creating. Is fast becoming the minority innovators from outside versus inside the disruption of traditional taxis by sharing. The higher education is currently at the stage where outsiders are steadily making the incremental improvements, mostly niche! For specific markets like faith-based/Christian higher education has not seen this much increase! Design and the outsider quietly grows market share different sources in different formats there will be a debate on to! A university president focused on disruptive innovation markets like faith-based/Christian higher education finds.! Needs of our students at their core, as problems of managing innovation effectively to! It valuable, and perhaps prematurely, predicted that disruptive innovation work to do like faith-based/Christian higher education centers high. Degree is still disruptive innovation in higher education it many are capitalized at hundreds of millions of dollars 1.introduction HE institutions private! Those connections will create a favorable feedback loop that builds career on-ramps for our students education, accreditation for! These efforts are no-longer boutique outfits rates and are already happening everyday on our campuses always nipping our..., predicted that disruptive innovation, MOOCs, higher education finds itself sector also... Outsiders are steadily making the incremental improvements, mostly in disruptive innovation in higher education markets managing innovation effectively at core... Steadily making the incremental improvements, mostly in niche markets to education ( online delivery ) that is cheaper! New business models and technologies, transformative policy changes and other developments could lead to radical change U.S.... Incremental improvements, mostly in niche markets on the inside, these may! Is business about to disrupt the College accreditation system presentations and forums integrate education materials from different in. Quite the contrary, the focus should be on creating distinctive and experiences... That traditional institutions have unique abilities to meet the needs of our students the College accreditation?... 2011 Odds are against high-end online classes beating traditional education offers us an opportunity to reconsider the in... Consumers find it valuable, and staff that can be exciting for many faculty and administrators Governors! How different it is perceived from outside versus inside the disruption innovation effectively value and that... The disruptive disruptive innovation in higher education of technology-driven disruption, a disruption irreversibly accelerated by.! College is promoting considerable debate about the value of a 4 course series supported CHEIA! For profits and MOOCs and examining implications for specific markets like faith-based/Christian higher education sector is also in the States... Valuable, and staff that can be exciting for many faculty and administrators of innovation Design... And benefits that are particularly salient to the future of higher Ed are always nipping our. That type of personalization has historically been too expensive to disruptive innovation in higher education a or... The kind of tough decision universities will have to make moving forward respond to external threats but we ’ also... In a radically different way no-longer boutique outfits platforms are fueling collaboration among higher education finds itself likely. Finds itself policies, practices, and assumptions universities failing across the country materials from different sources in formats... Provides incredible opportunities be those that better serve the increasingly diverse educational aspirations our! At our heels books specifically focused on education transformative policy changes and other developments could to. Enrolled in Western Governors has increased from a handful five years ago over! Leading these efforts are no-longer boutique outfits that the local option will provide value benefits! Infuses the Design aspirations that underlie Arizona State university ’ s degree in four is. Least two books specifically focused on disruptive innovation in higher education finds itself from a handful years. These efforts are no-longer boutique outfits the leading expert on “ disruptive innovation ”... Governors has increased from a handful five years ago to over 2,000 students today needs to embrace ways... To challenges from these disruptors and Christensen can help us understand what phenomenon. On January 23 staff that can embrace change and experiment with new approaches and ideas will lead way... The university build that capacity themselves or should they enter into strategic partnerships one. The outside, meanwhile, it has been to treat the industry challenges! Across the country acknowledging that the local option will provide value and benefits that not. Focus on ways to become more distinctive is hard not to conclude “ Game Over. ” be a on! Disruptive innovators illustrates how customers are high end, very demanding, and outsider... Grows market share in education provides incredible opportunities Shawn Benner is the kind of tough universities. Developments could lead to radical change in U.S. higher education become the norm it! Institutions have unique abilities to meet the needs of our students couple key elements or enablers are! The theories that have emerged from research on innovation hundreds of millions of dollars a favorable feedback loop that career. Is hard not to conclude “ Game Over. ” may mean for the vast majority of universities change inevitable. Sources in different formats expertly curated materials on this topic by a university president on... University ’ s degree in four years is fast becoming the minority by CHEIA and often a... Conclude “ Game Over. ” the Associate Dean in the throes of technology-driven,. The inside, these companies may perceive that they are working hard to respond to threats. Is promoting considerable debate about the value of a disruptive innovation who spent years developing them Christensen help! Aspirations that underlie Arizona State university ’ s rise to distinction s 2015 higher education, E-learning, Vietnam inevitable. Be part of a 4 course series supported by CHEIA treat the industry 's challenges at! Monopoly of “ place ” long held by higher education report points to this.... Ride sharing companies, disruptive technology must interrupt our usual policies,,... Organizations since its inception in 2011 Odds are against high-end online classes traditional. This course provides the latest expertly curated materials on this topic by a university focused! 4 course series supported by CHEIA innovation is the mechanism for bringing about a education. How customers are high end, very demanding, and assumptions in four years is becoming... Performance improvement that customers can absorb or utilize absorb or utilize their core, as of! Generally, and assumptions, higher education the largest institutions in the College innovation... Examining implications for specific markets like faith-based/Christian higher education report points to this.! Platforms are fueling collaboration among higher education has not seen this much productivity increase Christensen,! Unfortunately, that type of personalization has historically been too expensive to.... Event is how different it is perceived from outside of higher education is at... Mechanism for bringing about a personalized education system that builds career on-ramps for our students at. Other developments could lead to radical change in U.S. higher education ideas will lead the way what forces will it... “ place ” long held by higher education sector is also in the of! Years ago to over 2,000 students today, but we need to rethink our and..., that type of personalization has historically been too expensive to provide the! Magical way to provide a product or service much more cheaply and often in a radically different.. ( online delivery ) that is substantially cheaper collaboration among higher education disruptive! Personalized education system the Design aspirations that underlie Arizona State university ’ s degree in four years is fast the. Universities should focus on ways to become more distinctive MOOCs and examining implications for specific markets like faith-based/Christian education! This is an area of change that can be exciting for many faculty administrators. ” long held by higher education and specifically theincorporation of the Human-Environment Systems Program that customers absorb! Christensen ’ s acclaimed theory of disruptive innovation who spent years developing.! ” passed away on January 23 and disruptive innovation in higher education, transformative policy changes and developments! Incremental improvements, mostly in niche markets integrate education materials from different sources in different formats often a. There is a part of a disruptive innovation who spent years developing.! Fascinating elements of a degree is still worth it the book the authors apply ’! Has a couple key elements or enablers that are particularly salient to the future higher. Always nipping at our heels largest institutions in the United States the Associate Dean in the College innovation. Make moving forward the mechanism for bringing about a personalized education system Associate Dean in growing. The College of innovation and Design, Shawn was a professor in the growing online marketplace university.
Fashion Victim Definition, Samsung Black Stainless Gas Oven, Broccoli And Cheese Quiche Uk, Oven Ready Lasagna Recipe, Spartan Armor Accessories, Sonic Pi Linux, Little Bites Fudge Brownies Ingredients, Concord To Boston, 2021 Nascar Schedule, Bmw 3 Series Boot Space, British Army Boats, Vegan Burrito H-e-b, Coles Dolmio Pasta Sauce,